discussion Real or Not?

[ojays]

Just seen this on 'RAF Banter And Bollocks' there is controversy as to whether it is real, R/C or CGI

Your thoughts on this!

Gregg

 

[Alan 45]

I'd say RC I just slowed it down and there is no port side hatch that I could see

 

[Guest]

in my own opinion, judging from the lack of noise after it has flown past i would say scale rc.

 

[AlanG]

Without a doubt it isn't real lol. The wind buffeting you'd have got if that was real would have knocked the guys off his feet. Also too close to the hedges.

I personally think it's CGI. Sound is all wrong for a RC engine

 

[ojays]

This is a comment from a member of the 'CAF'

It's real alright. The C-47 belongs to the Commemorative Air Force based in Texas. If you think it's an RC, you don't know much about airplanes.

Gregg

 

[ojays]

Without a doubt it isn't real lol. The wind buffeting you'd have got if that was real would have knocked the guys off his feet. Also too close to the hedges.I personally think it's CGI. Sound is all wrong for a RC engine

I don't know if it is real or not, however if anyone had been standing I fear they wouldn't have been after it passed. Headless comes to mind

Gregg

 

[Guest]

Real fly by

 

[Guest]

I think having seen a few more vids its rc with audio dub work

 

[Alan 45]

Now you can see that the other one is not real

 

[Guest]

top vid deffo rc look at the scale diffrence here

 

[Guest]

To be honest if the first one was real it was an unbelievably irresponsible and stupid manoeuvre in any aircraft, never mind a fifty year old Dakota. I can therefore only hope it was RC!! If it was real the guy should loose his license.

 

[AlanG]

All i'll say is look at the size of the grass in front of the lens compared to the 'real' C-47

 

[eddiesolo]

It is RC, with over dubbed sound effects, still a good bit of video work and flying.

Si

 

[stona]

This is a comment from a member of the 'CAF'It's real alright. The C-47 belongs to the Commemorative Air Force based in Texas. If you think it's an RC, you don't know much about airplanes.

Gregg

That's called making yourself a hostage to fortune. I don't think it's a CAF aeroplane, if I had to bet I'd say a model. The scale is wrong relative to the environment as it flies by. I'd rather carry on sitting on the fence though.

Cheers

Steve

 

[flyjoe180]

This is a comment from a member of the 'CAF'It's real alright. The C-47 belongs to the Commemorative Air Force based in Texas. If you think it's an RC, you don't know much about airplanes.

Gregg

I'm afraid I better be looking for a new job then.