Use of star ratings.

[Guest]

I like, if the 5 stars is removed!

Prefer the comments, of all kind, of course. With they you learn a lot...

Ps: Alan!! Nobody is better than you! What are you saying??

Here, just all us do differents kind of modelling! Here there is no place for the best and worst modeller

[Alan 45]

I like, if the 5 stars is removed!Prefer the comments, of all kind, of course. With they you learn a lot...

Ps: Alan!! Nobody is better than you! What are you saying??

Here, just all us do differents kind of modelling! Here there is no place for the best and worst modeller

Polux mate I'm saying everybody is better than me I hope we aren't loseing ourselves in translation and your saying I'm good instead of me thinking you I've said I'm better than than I am

I'm sorry if I've missread your meaning and sorry if I've not made my point clear in my first post.

[Guest]

Yes I agree no stars. Daft system as most are 5 stars. Not seen a 1 2 3 or 4. So the system makes no sense at all. But I can see that members say "5 stars" as a well done rather than a standard of excellence. That is how I see it which is nice.

Best way is to say in text what you consider to be of interest. Think to point out the good & excellent things about a model is helpful to those who are relatively new to model making or those wishing to improve their technique in a particular way. Also to add how something may be improved or missed a delicate thing to do!That does not worry me as I am out to learn. Perhaps if you want comments to give free rein by saying comments welcome ( or only good ones welcome ! ). Then you cannot take umbridge.

Laurie

[Ian M]

Well thats settled. If you like a biuld and think it deserves a gong, that is now the only option. Note the choice of word OPTION if you dont want to use it, then dont.

I to agree that an honest critique here and there is worth far more than a gong.

As John has said the star rating system is history.

My last word on this use of the forum for completed builds is please try to put them in the right sections...

Ian M