Scale Model Shop

Collapse

Model kits...poor fitting.

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • stona
    • Jul 2008
    • 9889

    #16
    Originally posted by \
    Point taken Steve, but I've built lots of short-run kits that had reasonable fit; the Marivox kit was just downright poor. I certainly wasn't expecting a Tamiya/Eduard quality production.
    Hi Mike, I've just been looking at your Avia by RS (they do some interesting Luftwaffe stuff too) so I know that you are a very experienced model builder who knows what to expect from these kits, whilst hoping for the best

    I just wanted to explain to some who might never have attempted the sort of short run, limited production kits that you have mastered that they can be quite challenging.

    Sometimes they can fit well as you say. I built a kit by Fly recently that fitted almost perfectly and was pleasantly surprised. Others are rather more vague, you know, the ones where it seems like the bloke who did the wings never spoke to the one who did the fuselage

    Cheers

    Steve

    Comment

    • yak face
      Moderator
      • Jun 2009
      • 14078
      • Tony
      • Sheffield

      #17
      Originally posted by \
      Hi Mike, I've just been looking at your Avia by RS (they do some interesting Luftwaffe stuff too) so I know that you are a very experienced model builder who knows what to expect from these kits, whilst hoping for the best I just wanted to explain to some who might never have attempted the sort of short run, limited production kits that you have mastered that they can be quite challenging.

      Sometimes they can fit well as you say. I built a kit by Fly recently that fitted almost perfectly and was pleasantly surprised. Others are rather more vague, you know, the ones where it seems like the bloke who did the wings never spoke to the one who did the fuselage

      Cheers

      Steve
      You should try something by Amodel , now THATS a vague fit!!

      Comment

      • eddiesolo
        • Jul 2013
        • 11193

        #18
        Some good points and issues raised by some very talented model makers, superb input so thank you guys for that.

        I suppose for me, as I have said, the sticking point is the fit for people with disability issues, my modelling has dropped off due to the time being taken to rectify fits and faff. I know it isn't a race and sometimes things will not always work out, but still a frustrating thing to happen, especially when cost involving certain models is involved.

        Si

        Comment

        • Guest

          #19
          One of the problems with manufacturers is that they know they can get away with their kits not being so good. Each who buys a kit is an individualist & most just get on with it & put up with it.

          If we all said this is not good enough then standards would improve. But how many of us take the trouble to moan ?

          Very few I suspect & so things just carry on as before.

          It is all who has got the cat by it's tail. Them or us. On the other side, being devil's advocate, we will all moan if the cost of models go up due to the extra effort of manufactures to make things more near perfect.

          Can understand SI's predicament & the best there is to chose those models which are brand new as this seems to be the best way of getting something of the best fit.

          Plus having read sometimes that somebody in producing the same model, as I have, has encountered a problem which I have not & vice-versa. So some of the problems I suspect are in the way we tackle a model & that a lot of forethought should be given to the planning of the construction & not to follow willy nilly the instruction sheets provided.

          How many of us have said to ourselves wish I had thought that out better ?

          Laurie

          Comment

          • stona
            • Jul 2008
            • 9889

            #20
            Si I've always said that patience is the most important tool in the cupboard.

            You just can't rush. The frustration of effing up all by myself by trying to rush was worse than just effing up anyway!

            Cheers

            Steve

            Comment

            • The Migrant
              • Apr 2011
              • 1268

              #21
              Originally posted by \
              One of the problems with manufacturers is that they know they can get away with their kits not being so good. Each who buys a kit is an individualist & most just get on with it & put up with it.
              It's true that many manufacturers continue to sell the same old kits in new boxes. Airfix are the only example I can think of as a company that is slowly working its way through many of its older toolings and replacing them with brand new, well-fitting accurised versions, yet still at an affordable price. (They also seem to be a bit more selective about the older toolings that they're still releasing, some of the worst from the 60s haven't shown up yet in the new red boxes). However 'old' isn't necessarily synonymous with 'poor fitting'; I've built a lot of classic kits from Heller, Matchbox and Airfix that have been very good requiring only small amounts of filler, and as Laurie pointed out even that can be avoided sometimes by careful forethought and whittling away at plastic before gluing.



              Sometimes they can fit well as you say. I built a kit by Fly recently that fitted almost perfectly and was pleasantly surprised. Others are rather more vague, you know, the ones where it seems like the bloke who did the wings never spoke to the one who did the fuselage
              I have the perfect example of that scenario, Steve I'll post it later.

              Comment

              • ojays
                • Oct 2011
                • 1713

                #22
                Originally posted by \
                One of the problems with manufacturers is that they know they can get away with their kits not being so good. Each who buys a kit is an individualist & most just get on with it & put up with it.If we all said this is not good enough then standards would improve. But how many of us take the trouble to moan ?

                Very few I suspect & so things just carry on as before.

                It is all who has got the cat by it's tail. Them or us. On the other side, being devil's advocate, we will all moan if the cost of models go up due to the extra effort of manufactures to make things more near perfect.

                Can understand SI's predicament & the best there is to chose those models which are brand new as this seems to be the best way of getting something of the best fit.

                Plus having read sometimes that somebody in producing the same model, as I have, has encountered a problem which I have not & vice-versa. So some of the problems I suspect are in the way we tackle a model & that a lot of forethought should be given to the planning of the construction & not to follow willy nilly the instruction sheets provided.

                How many of us have said to ourselves wish I had thought that out better ?

                Laurie
                As to your last line Laurie,

                This is where the forum comes in with advice, ideas and experiences etc..

                One persons bad experience is another mans solution (or something like that)o_Oo_O Well I know what I mean

                Gregg

                Comment

                Working...