Scale Model Shop

Collapse

Dave W's Revell 1/48 Tornado ADV Saudi Air Force

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dave W
    • Jan 2011
    • 4713

    #46
    Originally posted by tr1ckey66
    Hi Dave
    I wasn't implying that you didn't test fit before hand. I know your work, and I know you know what you're doing. Truth is, it looks a poor fit (even on the box art). Now that you've highlighted the problem I'm wondering if minor surgery to the parts might be required?

    This might seem crazy, but I now have three of these Revell kits: two GR4s and an IDS. Your experience has me concerned. I may use the IDS version as a test mule to analyse the build (without paint) and highlight the fit issues, and what the best course of action is to remedy them. Once I've done that I'll build the other two, keeping the mule in case I need to break it open to replace wings with broken flap attachments.

    I'm completely confident that you'll sort the intakes Dave and I'm grateful for your insight into the kit, one modeller to another.
    All the best
    Paul
    Hi Paul. I didnt think you were implying anything. I have been building kits for many years. But i still make the occasional cock up. In this case i have been careful to get it right. And still im having problems. As soon as i saw the parts break down i knew i was in for a difficult build. Im just disappointed that a new mold kit is this bad. 2 years ago i built the Tamiya 1/32 Mosquito. Hundreds of parts that all fitted together perfectly. And no filler needed. So why cant Revell make kits like that?. If only Tamiya did a Tornado.

    Comment

    • tr1ckey66
      SMF Supporters
      • Mar 2009
      • 3592

      #47
      If only Tamiya did a Tornado.
      Yep, that would be very nice. A 1/32 one would be even more lovely for me!

      I guess the difference between the Mozzy and the Revell Tonka is about £100!
      I'm not being flippant here I know exactly what you mean. A new kit, with all that CAD and moulding technology, should come together pretty well regardless of price.

      Having built a few of the new Revell kits (1/32 Spitfire II, 1/32 109G-6 etc) I've noticed that I've needed to build a couple of kits just to get used to the model's character, get to know the plastic so-to-speak. The Spitfire for instance has undercarriage that's a little too fragile (a combination of the oleo's small diameter and the soft plastic Revell uses) and fuselage sides that are a little too wide for the canopy. Because these kits are relatively cheap I've found it's worth buying an extra kit just to investigate the flaws, especially if you're adding aftermarket stuff. It ain't ideal but I've been able to identify the pitfalls and find a solution to them. It looks like this Tornado is going to be yet another puzzler.

      Anyhoo, stick with the build and tame those intakes.
      I'll join you for the Big Tonka build. That's if you don't decide to build your ZM Phantom!

      Cheers
      P

      Comment

      • stillp
        SMF Supporters
        • Nov 2016
        • 8226
        • Pete
        • Rugby

        #48
        Looking at the photos in the first post, the 1:1 doesn't seem to fit very well either.

        Pete

        Comment

        • Dave W
          • Jan 2011
          • 4713

          #49
          Originally posted by tr1ckey66
          Yep, that would be very nice. A 1/32 one would be even more lovely for me!

          I guess the difference between the Mozzy and the Revell Tonka is about £100!
          I'm not being flippant here I know exactly what you mean. A new kit, with all that CAD and moulding technology, should come together pretty well regardless of price.

          Having built a few of the new Revell kits (1/32 Spitfire II, 1/32 109G-6 etc) I've noticed that I've needed to build a couple of kits just to get used to the model's character, get to know the plastic so-to-speak. The Spitfire for instance has undercarriage that's a little too fragile (a combination of the oleo's small diameter and the soft plastic Revell uses) and fuselage sides that are a little too wide for the canopy. Because these kits are relatively cheap I've found it's worth buying an extra kit just to investigate the flaws, especially if you're adding aftermarket stuff. It ain't ideal but I've been able to identify the pitfalls and find a solution to them. It looks like this Tornado is going to be yet another puzzler.

          Anyhoo, stick with the build and tame those intakes.
          I'll join you for the Big Tonka build. That's if you don't decide to build your ZM Phantom!

          Cheers
          P
          The first thing to look out for is when u fit the forward fuselage halves around the cockpit. Part of the fuselage inter fears with the rear instrument panel. Panel needs to be placed in loose until after fuselage halves are together. Intake ducts go together ok. Next big problem is those intakes. Might have helped if I'd thinned out the plastic along their rear ,vertical edges.The wings on the other hand go together well.Even the swing wing mechanism fits well and works. Although it's a bit pointless if like me you want the flaps and slats out.

          Comment

          • tr1ckey66
            SMF Supporters
            • Mar 2009
            • 3592

            #50
            Thank you Dave. I'll be sure and take your experiences into my builds. And I'll be sure to share my thoughts with you when I do.

            This is, for me, the real reason I continue with the forum. An honest conversation with helpful pointers. :thumb2:
            Cheers
            Paul

            Comment

            • Dave W
              • Jan 2011
              • 4713

              #51
              Intakes are looking better after filling and sanding.

              [ATTACH]293659[/ATTACH][ATTACH]293660[/ATTACH]
              Attached Files

              Comment

              • yak face
                Moderator
                • Jun 2009
                • 14080
                • Tony
                • Sheffield

                #52
                Looking better now Dave, as Rick says its very surprising considering this is a brand new tooling . Like the Airfix Lightning,you wonder how it got past the test build stage without someone noticing the poor fit. Are the 1/48 Revell gr1/4 s like this too? if so then it looks like I'll be getting the Italeri for my build!

                Comment

                • Dave W
                  • Jan 2011
                  • 4713

                  #53
                  This must be the same kit as the GR1 with a longer nose added for the ADV. Theres a top fuselage section in this kit or the GR1. I know because i glued it on by mistake!. Anyway, drama over now. Im going to rescribe a few lines and carry on with the build.

                  Comment

                  • peterairfix
                    • Jul 2012
                    • 11109

                    #54
                    Originally posted by yak face
                    Looking better now Dave, as Rick says its very surprising considering this is a brand new tooling . Like the Airfix Lightning,you wonder how it got past the test build stage without someone noticing the poor fit. Are the 1/48 Revell gr1/4 s like this too? if so then it looks like I'll be getting the Italeri for my build!
                    I have a 1\48 gr1 sitting on my shelf been there since last may as I just can't tackle all the terrible fit issues.
                    As I have been watching quietly and it seems much the same problems as mine.

                    Comment

                    • tr1ckey66
                      SMF Supporters
                      • Mar 2009
                      • 3592

                      #55
                      Great work Dave. I think you're over the worst now.
                      Those intakes look mighty fine!
                      Cheers
                      Paul

                      Comment

                      • Dave W
                        • Jan 2011
                        • 4713

                        #56
                        Originally posted by peterairfix
                        I have a 1\48 gr1 sitting on my shelf been there since last may as I just can't tackle all the terrible fit issues.
                        As I have been watching quietly and it seems much the same problems as mine.
                        Its disappointing to have these fit issues in a new kit. But youve built a couple of Airfix 1/24 Spitfires Peter. So this one shouldnt present too many problems for you.

                        Comment

                        • peterairfix
                          • Jul 2012
                          • 11109

                          #57
                          Originally posted by Dave W
                          Its disappointing to have these fit issues in a new kit. But youve built a couple of Airfix 1/24 Spitfires Peter. So this one shouldnt present too many problems for you.
                          You might have just inspired me perhaps after my current build I just might take it off the shelf of doom and start giving it a good seeing to.

                          Comment

                          • Dave W
                            • Jan 2011
                            • 4713

                            #58
                            Originally posted by peterairfix
                            You might have just inspired me perhaps after my current build I just might take it off the shelf of doom and start giving it a good seeing to.
                            Why not?. You could join the Tornado build!

                            Comment

                            • papa 695
                              Moderator
                              • May 2011
                              • 22851

                              #59
                              Great work Dave keep at it you will win.

                              Comment

                              • peterairfix
                                • Jul 2012
                                • 11109

                                #60
                                Originally posted by Dave W
                                Why not?. You could join the Tornado build!
                                And this is why I didn't[ATTACH]293708[/ATTACH]
                                Attached Files

                                Comment

                                Working...