1/35 Bronco Bishop SPG - forum choice
- Thread starter Dave Ward
- Start date
Nice sunny morning here, listening to the wood pigeons cooing & wooing.................
I fitted the rear engine doors - rather puzzled. as I can't see any hinges in the instructions - there's a hole, but nowhere in the assembly can I find anything to put in it!
I decided to look at how MiniArt do this on their Valentine, and found something odd......................
MiniArt Valentine Instructions
If you look at the Bronco Instructions for the same assembly:
The Bronco has a few more parts, but look at the part numbers - they're so similar, it can't be a coincidence!
According to Scalemates, there's no connection between Bronco & MiniArt, but...........................
Dave
I fitted the rear engine doors - rather puzzled. as I can't see any hinges in the instructions - there's a hole, but nowhere in the assembly can I find anything to put in it!
I decided to look at how MiniArt do this on their Valentine, and found something odd......................
MiniArt Valentine Instructions
If you look at the Bronco Instructions for the same assembly:
The Bronco has a few more parts, but look at the part numbers - they're so similar, it can't be a coincidence!
According to Scalemates, there's no connection between Bronco & MiniArt, but...........................
Dave
Upper deck primed & basecoated................................
I've still to add the exhaust heat shield & tools, but that part is finished. The Gun & tower can just about be finished as a separate assembly. If I thought some of the hull was tricky & overengineered, then the gun is at a new level!
Dave
I've still to add the exhaust heat shield & tools, but that part is finished. The Gun & tower can just about be finished as a separate assembly. If I thought some of the hull was tricky & overengineered, then the gun is at a new level!
Dave
After almost a week, I'm back to the bench. I've had a bad back, which has meant that I have spent a lot of time lying down. It's now just very stiff, but I can at least sit properly.
I've added the tracks & united the upper & lower hull.........................
I'm not going to add the top track runs, they will be hidden by the sand shields. The individual track links aren't particularly difficult, just annoyingly fiddly and boring, so no point in spending time on something that won't be seen
Dave
I've added the tracks & united the upper & lower hull.........................
I'm not going to add the top track runs, they will be hidden by the sand shields. The individual track links aren't particularly difficult, just annoyingly fiddly and boring, so no point in spending time on something that won't be seen
Dave
G
Look complex to me Dave, smart move with those tracks.
G
Sorry to hear you've been out of action Dave. Build is looking good though.
Hi Dave
Just caught up on this. It's looking very nicely done and I can't blame you for not doing the tracks.
Also sorry to hear about the back. I suffer with mine too sometimes, so you have my utmost sympathy.
Keep up the good work.
Andrew
Just caught up on this. It's looking very nicely done and I can't blame you for not doing the tracks.
Also sorry to hear about the back. I suffer with mine too sometimes, so you have my utmost sympathy.
Keep up the good work.
Andrew
On to the gun...............................
A really overcomplicated assembly, not helped by one actual part bearing no resemblance to the drawing - I hunted on all the sprues, to find a part that resembled this, but no. This is 17 parts ( I've omitted two tiny PE parts )
I can understand making the breech able to be assembled open/shut, but Bronco would have you make it as a working part, opened by the breech lever - no way!
The mounting for the gun is one of two options. The instructions don't say if they are late, or early, or apply to a particular theatre - I'm going to look, and see if one is easier to make than the other.
Dave
A really overcomplicated assembly, not helped by one actual part bearing no resemblance to the drawing - I hunted on all the sprues, to find a part that resembled this, but no. This is 17 parts ( I've omitted two tiny PE parts )
I can understand making the breech able to be assembled open/shut, but Bronco would have you make it as a working part, opened by the breech lever - no way!
The mounting for the gun is one of two options. The instructions don't say if they are late, or early, or apply to a particular theatre - I'm going to look, and see if one is easier to make than the other.
Dave
Maybe they both outsourced to the same tech writer? Looks very complex & well built anyhow. PaulE
Hi Dave
Hope your back is fully better.
That is a complex kit with instructions that could be better. Where you're at now is looking great. The detail really shows up with the paint.
Jim
Hope your back is fully better.
That is a complex kit with instructions that could be better. Where you're at now is looking great. The detail really shows up with the paint.
Jim
G
Dave,
Ref similar parts and instructions, I have a Tamiya Bradley and Academy Bradley same parts and part numbers.
You say you seem to be doing a lot for what looks like little return - we can see it.
Cheers,
Mike.
Ref similar parts and instructions, I have a Tamiya Bradley and Academy Bradley same parts and part numbers.
You say you seem to be doing a lot for what looks like little return - we can see it.
Cheers,
Mike.
G
Academy got their start in life by straight up copying Tamiya kits without asking for permission
Not sure what the deal is with this Bronco kit, though.
Back to the Bishop ( I'm blogging a bust on another forum ). Again, a lot of effort seems to bring small advances...............
Mount & sight parts - all individual asssemblies - there are still some smaller (!!) bits to add, and PE........................
I have however drawn the line at certain parts - OK, it was always going to be the case with some PE, but some of the plastic parts?
Against a standard 10A Scalpel blade - I can barely see them in real life, and they won't be missed from the sight assembly deep inside the housing. This is turning into a marathon assembly!!
Dave
Mount & sight parts - all individual asssemblies - there are still some smaller (!!) bits to add, and PE........................
I have however drawn the line at certain parts - OK, it was always going to be the case with some PE, but some of the plastic parts?
Against a standard 10A Scalpel blade - I can barely see them in real life, and they won't be missed from the sight assembly deep inside the housing. This is turning into a marathon assembly!!
Dave
I feel sorry for the die tool maker! I'm just going to ignore those tiny parts..................
Dave
Dave
Dave, I was warned once about the tiny parts and count on the Valentine and Bishop. If the part can't be seen from any angle viewed I'd leave it off as long as it's not holding something together.
Cheers,
Richard
Cheers,
Richard
Legal Notice
scalemodelling.co.uk is a privately operated online discussion forum. All content posted by members reflects their own views and opinions and does not necessarily represent those of the forum owners or administrators. While reasonable efforts are made to moderate content, no responsibility is accepted for user-generated material. By using this site, you agree to comply with UK law and the forum rules.